— Frequently Asked Questions —
We are located on the southeast side of Indianapolis near Wanamaker, IN. Our address is 7639 Southeastern Ave Suite B, Indianapolis, IN 46239. This is off Southeastern Ave. between Fisher Rd. and Ferguson Rd.
Our building sits back off the street and is across from the Generations Grill (a red, white, and blue building).
If you pull into a parking lot that has Silhouette's Hair Salon, Hot Rod Hair Salon, and Kara's Lucky Dog Training, you are in the right place! Just go over the speed bumps and head toward the back of that parking lot.
We stop taking orders approximately 30 minutes before closing time (hours of operation are listed at the bottom of each webpage).
For example, if we close at 8 PM, we stop taking orders any time between 7:30 to 8 PM.
If you call and either no one answers or it seems like the phones are "off," we are likely closed for the day. For this reason, we do not recommend showing up at Xtrordinary Pizza without calling.
Hours fluctuate based on ingredient availability, busyness, holidays, etc. All closures are typically posted on our Facebook page (linked at the bottom of each webpage), so you can also check there.
Yes, we have gift certificates available for purchase. You can purchase a gift certificate of any amount at the Xtrordinary Pizza counter.
We accept cash and all major credit and debit card companies. However, there is a $1 charge for using a credit or debit card. We do not accept checks.
No. At this time, we do not offer dine-in and do not plan to return to dine-in. We are strictly carry out only.
No. At this time, we do not offer delivery and do not plan to return to delivery. We are strictly carry out only.
Yes! Please call Xtrordinary Pizza at (317) 862-2960 to place a pre-order. All pre-orders need to be placed with a 1.5-2 hour notice.
No. At this time, we do not offer any military and/or senior discounts.
It depends! We offer 1/2 and 1/2 on 16" Large pizzas and 10" Medium pizzas only. We do not offer 1/2 and 1/2 on the 7" Personal Pan pizzas.
We only offer 1/2 and 1/2, we do not offer 1/4 or 1/3.
Additionally, if you get a 1/2 and 1/2 on a 10" Medium pizza, the pizza must be cut into triangles. We do not cut 1/2 and 1/2 10" Medium pizzas in squares.
No, we do not offer a gluten-free pizza crust. However, we have a crustless pizza bowl option available.
No, our only meat options are pepperoni, sausage, and ham.
No, we do not offer salads.
We use a hand-tossed style crust.
The 16" Large pizza can be cut into 8 triangles or 16 squares.
The 10" Medium pizza can be cut into 8 triangles or 9 squares. However, we do not cut 1/2 and 1/2 10" Medium pizzas into squares.
The 7" Personal Pan pizza is cut into 4 triangles. It is too small to be cut into squares.